Richie thinks he has finally found his one true love when he begins a whirlwind romance with a woman in San Francisco. Risking everything he decides to take a surprise trip to SF and profess his love to her only to discover she is married. Heartbroken and crushed he returns to Los Angeles to put his life back together. Michelle, also recently heartbroken by a cheating boyfriend has given up men. Her best friends Amy and Kinzi are truly worried about her. Amy is married to a true romantic Logan and Kinzi is spoiled by her infatuated boyfriend Dan. Through a chance encounter on the beach and via the fact Michelle rents a room from Amy, Michelle and Richie soon start hanging out and spending time together. makes an appearance as a wild actress/musician who dates Richie's friend Tommy, and stirs up a dinner party by sneaking off to the bathroom for a quickie. Will Mischa and Richie eventually decide to take the plunge back into the ocean of love again?